Your Verdict. Your Case.  -  Save $50 When You Mix & Match Any 6 Bottles

Hand Down Your Verdict

You’ve examined the evidence and tasted the spirits. It is time to enter your final judgment into the record.
The Subject
On what grounds did you reach this decision?
On what grounds did you reach this decision?
The verdict is in. Your judgment has been recorded.

The Customers Have Spoken

Brown sugar was my favorite I really like the smooth sweet taste.

Donna Grimsley
September 13, 2026

Smooth drinking whiskey

Donna Grimsley
September 13, 2026

Not Guilty, the brown sugar bourbon, is really good, even for someone who doesn’t normally drink bourbon.

N Williams
September 5, 2026

The price point is great, and the flavor delivers and finishes perfectly. This might become my daily drinker !

Rich P
September 2, 2026

I have bought six guilty and six not guilty totally enjoy it. I’m a big whiskey lover with other more expensive brands but this is the best. Highly recommended an A+ in my book.

Anthony Ramirez
August 27, 2026

I purchased both to gift to a good client, who is very wealthy and has nothing but the best. I noticed in their “social social room” the bottle was empty in a week.

Thanks for a great product

Thomas Tolomeo
July 31, 2026

This is some straight coon juice! I see why it has to be ordered ON ITS ON WEBSITE! JUST LIKE THEM ⚪ PPL U ❤️SO MUCH WON’T PUT IT IN THEIR STORES! MY AUNT NANCY TOWED, CRUSHED & MELTED YO “BUY ME, IM FOR SALE!” LYING raCCOON! “IM STARTING TO SMELL THAT “WET DAWG” SMELL. IM CONFUSED. HELP ME UNDERSTAND HOW A SNOW BUNNY SMELL LIKE A WET DAWG? U USE TO THAT SMELL BY NOW! I WANNA KNOW WHEN U GUNNA TELL YA OLE GAL THAT ASHLEE COLE BOUT TO BE HER SONS STEPMOM! THAT WAS CUTE, U INTERVIEWED YA STEPSON LIL WARRIOR….I THINK THAT’S HIS NAME, U KNOW WHO IM TALKING ABOUT, THE WHITE KID U INTERVIEWED FOR FREE CAUSE ASHLEE SAID THAT SHE WAS GOING TO TELL YA SNOW BUNNY

NOLAN WELLS
July 30, 2026

A decent product

Doug
July 18, 2026

Decent product

Doug
July 18, 2026

Fantastic Bourbon with a nice sweet note and a very pleasant smokey note at the end. This would make an outstanding bourbon to use in a BBQ sauce recipe. I will be purchasing more in the future (if available). Get yours now while it’s available.

Randall Hoover
June 28, 2026

Outstanding bourbon that presents itself much older than the 6 years printed on the bottle. I have several bottles of bourbon 10 years or older that aren’t nearly as smooth as this 6 years old tastes . I definitely give a 5 out of 5 rating.

Randall Hoover
June 28, 2026

Gave to my Son-in-law for birthday and retirement gift. He loves Old Fashions and good bourbon. Gave Guilty a 9 out of 10. Bottle didn’t last long 🥰👍

Dianne Truelove
June 25, 2026
© Verdict Whiskey. All rights reserved
Follow Us
Website Design by:
My Biz Niche